Michigan CEOs to GOP: Don’t disenfranchise voters

June 23: GOP investigation finds no Michigan vote fraud, deems many claims ‘ludicrous’

LANSING — Business leaders from some of Michigan’s largest employers on Tuesday urged the state’s Republican-led Legislature to avoid approving any new election laws that would reduce participation or disenfranchise voters. 

General Motors CEO Mary Barra, Ford CEO Jim Farley and Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan CEO Daniel Loepp were among those who spoke out as legislators begin to debate a 39-bill election reform package introduced by state Senate Republicans.

The business leaders did not object to any specific bills — which include proposals for strict voter ID laws, new regulations for absentee ballot drop boxes and a ban on pre-paid return postage — but urged “equitable access” to the ballot box.

Related:

• Michigan has 1,100 voter drop boxes. GOP plan would lock them early.
• Q&A: Should CEO’s address social issues or stick to selling sneakers?
• Activists want to oust Michigan GOP director for saying Trump ‘blew it’ in 2020
• GOP wants to split Michigan Electoral College votes. That would help the GOP.
• Toyota resumes giving to Michigan Republicans who voted to overturn election
• Pressure on Michigan businesses to take a position on GOP voting bills
• Michigan GOP voting plan has much in common with Georgia law. How they compare
• We read all Michigan election reform bills. Many would add hurdles to voting.
• How Republicans plan to tighten Michigan voting laws, evade Whitmer veto

“Government must avoid actions that reduce participation in elections —  particularly among historically disenfranchised communities, persons with disabilities, older adults, racial minorities and low-income voters,” they said in a joint statement. 

“Election laws must be developed in a bipartisan fashion to preserve public confidence in our elections and to preserve the values of democracy.”

Other signers include: DTE Energy President Jerry Norcia and Penske Corporation chair Roger Penske, Quicken Loans CEO Jay Farner, American Axle CEO David Dauch and Magna International CEO Swamy Kotagiri. 

All four of Michigan’s major professional sports teams also were represented, with Detroit Lions CEO Ron Wood and Detroit Pistons’ Vice Chairman Arn Tellem signing the letter along with Ilitch Holdings CEO Christopher Illitch, representing multiple businesses that include the Detroit Red Wings and Detroit Tigers. 

Asked about the letter, Senate Majority Leader Mike Shirkey said he welcomes input as the bills move through the legislative process in coming weeks or months. 

“At all times we must use logic, not political sentiment or ‘wokeness,’ to build good public policy that will serve all Michiganders and safeguard our democracy,” Shirkey, R-Clarklake, said in a statement. 

"If having an ID is viewed as an obstacle to voting because there is a problem getting an ID, let’s solve that problem."

Several of the corporations are major political donors who for years have helped fill the campaign coffers of both Republicans and Democrats in the Michigan Legislature.

In 2019 and 2020 alone, Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan’s political action committee gave more than $1 million to state-level candidates and committees, including a $20,000 contribution to the Senate Republican Campaign Committee, according to campaign finance reports. 

DTE Energy’s PAC reported more than $640,000 in state-level political spending over the past two years, along with $239,000 from Ford and $222,000 from General Motors.

The statement released Tuesday follows a meeting over the weekend of what was reported as dozens of CEOs of leading U.S. companies weighing reaction to the changes in voting laws proposed in states like Texas, where Gov. Jim Abbott has told businesses to stay out of politics.

According to the Brenner Center for Justice at New York University, as of March 24, legislators nationwide introduced 361 bills containing new voting restrictions in 47 states. 

Some have been enacted, including in Georgia, where many businesses reacted strongly to them — yet critics say that happened too late to have any effect.

While the CEOs did not address specifics in Michigan’s proposals that alarmed them, GM CEO Mary Barra followed the joint statement on Tuesday by underscoring the leaders are weighing in before more restrictive laws can be passed.

“In advance of hearings on proposed voting law changes in our home state of Michigan, we want to reiterate our belief that the right to vote is the essence of a democratic society and that the voice of every voter should be heard in elections that are conducted with integrity,” Barra said in a statement.

Critics have called the Senate GOP bills a “voter suppression” package that would disproportionately impact Black and low-income voters who may be less likely to have photo identification and live in urban areas where drop boxes were heavily used last year.

The bills also would make it easier for Republicans to block the certification of countywide elections and mandate that cities complete election tallies by noon the day after elections, which could be an issue in large, typically Democratic cities like Detroit, Grand Rapids and Flint.

Rally at the Capitol

Hours after businesses came out against the election package, the NAACP, ACLU of Michigan and other groups rallied against the bills on the steps of the Michigan Capitol.

The Rev. Tellis Chapman of Galilee Missionary Baptist Church in Detroit, accused Republicans of changing voting rules “every doggone time democracy begins to win in the right way.”

“We are now dealing with Jim Crowe's grandchildren. They wear tailor-made suits,” Chapman told the crowd of about 100. “They don’t want us to vote at all.”

Detroit Mayor Mike Duggan called the bills “morally reprehensible” and said they would make Michigan voting laws similar to those in Georgia.

Duggan noted that as soon as Georgia passed its election laws and businesses complained, Republicans in Congress — including Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky — told businesses to not get involved in politics. 

“The first time the business people disagree with the ruling group, they're told they can't participate, it's not right for them,” Duggan said. “Well, the people in Detroit have been listening to that message for a while. It's not right when it's done for people of color, it’s not right when it's done for the poor, it's not right when it's done for anybody.”

In a statement to Bridge Michigan, a spokesman for the Michigan GOP said the bills are meant to protect the integrity of the electoral process. 

“Our public officials have an obligation to continuously improve and strengthen our election processes because public faith in the security and integrity of our elections is fundamental," said GOP spokesperson Ted Goodman. 

"We won't stand for lies and mischaracterizations from the left when it comes to election integrity efforts to preserve public confidence in our elections, and to preserve democracy."

Clerks disagree with bills

The election package has been criticized by clerks, who warn that requiring voters to mail a copy of their ID with an absentee ballot application could open them up to identity theft, and cautioned that allowing political party challengers to videotape ballot tabulation could intimidate voters or expose their ballots.

Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, a Democrat, has vowed to veto any election bills that make voting harder, but the Michigan Republican Party is already planning a petition drive to circumvent her using the citizen initiative process, chair Ron Weiser said last month. 

Under Michigan’s Constitution, if the GOP is able to collect 340,047 signatures for initiative legislation, the Legislature has the authority to enact the proposal into law without review by Whitmer or a vote of the people.

“There’s just so much in there that’s nibbling away at what a majority of voters wanted in 2018,” said Sen. Erika Geiss, D-Taylor, referencing a ballot initiative that enshrined no-reason absentee voting and other voter rights in the Michigan constitution. 

“Since they can’t change the constitution without another ballot proposal, they’re using the legislative process to nibble around that.”

Shirkey defended the legislation in a Monday interview on Jackson TV,  arguing it is designed to build voter confidence in the process. 

“I was disappointed in the outcome of the election, but what disappointed me more than that was the number of people who concluded that the election was suspect,” he said.

Those suspicions were fueled by false claims from Republican former President Donald Trump and his supporters, who alleged widespread voter fraud but relied on suspect evidence and were repeatedly rebuffed by courts. 

President Joe Biden, a Democrat, won Michigan by 154,188 votes in election results that have withstood several subsequent audits. 

“We haven’t found any evidence of fraud that would have changed the outcome, but we found plenty of evidence of people questioning whether or not the process (had) adequate integrity,” Shirkey said. 

Introducing legislation in the state Senate was the first in a “multi-step process,” he added. “I think there’s room for negotiation — (on) some of the bills.”

Among the people signing the business group statement was Sandy Baruah, president and CEO of the Detroit Regional Chamber of Commerce, the only business advocacy group represented among the 37 signatures. 

“Some elements of our society face higher hurdles to vote, including restricted personal resources and more difficult polling place access – and these issues must be addressed,” Baruah said in a statement explaining the chamber’s position on Monday.  

He went on to say that the chamber considers supporting voter rights to be an economic issue. 

“Michigan businesses compete nationally and internationally for diverse talent to remain competitive,” Baruah said. “ More restrictive voting rules send an unwelcoming message to prospective talent and hinder our state’s economic competitiveness. “

Brian Calley, president of the Small Business Association of Michigan, told Bridge last week that he was unlikely to link his group to the effort due to the economic pressures its members are facing amid the pandemic. 

Wendy Block, vice president of government affairs for the Michigan Chamber of Commerce, said last week the group was reviewing the election proposals and had not yet determined its position.